All posts tagged with legal opinion
Aliens: Colonial Marines

If BioWare had shown Kelly in the trailers for the Mass Effect 3 Citadel DLC, I’d be pissed — because they completely left her out of the final product. I’m still pissed, but I’d be even more pissed if they had my hopes up.

A (somewhat) similar issue occurred with Aliens: Colonial Marines. The game was possibly the worst game ever made (in 2013). Our own review called it “an embarrassment that should never have been released”.

This was particularly cutting because the work in progress demonstration trailer had previously showed a far better game. Some gamers were so riled up that they launched a class action lawsuit against Sega and Gearbox for false advertising.

Opinion around the interwebs has been divided. While most players support the lawsuit, some just aren’t sure whether it has a chance of succeeding. Today, we’ll be looking at whether the Aliens: Colonial Marines pre-release demonstration trailer was false advertising enough to give grounds for a lawsuit.

Bankruptcy

From the debacle that was 38 Studios, to the sadness of THQ’s closure, studios and publishers go bankrupt all the time. Much-loved gaming franchises linger in limbo as their publishers just… run out of money.

The only chance these games have is if a new publisher comes along and “buys the IP”. We see these words on gaming websites often. But what does “buying the IP” involve, anyway?

NRA

I’ll tell you why games do not cause murders. Of course, you already know this. However, with all the negative attention games have received on this topic lately, it’s good to look at how games may actually influence the minds of killers. (And to justify that trollish headline.)

Because really, any violent media can inspire someone to kill in a certain way—including video games. It’s been proven. But while the anti-gaming lobby would have you believe that this means games cause murder and should be censored, they are very much mistaken.

To understand why, we need to look at what leads people to murder.

The Secret World

Back in the nineties, Lara Croft was actually a man. Yet Larry Croft never saw the light of day, because one sex symbol named Larry was quite enough. Okay, well, actually, Tomb Raider’s creators vetoed him for being too similar to Indiana Jones. Then, they went back to the drawing board.

This hasn’t stopped other developers from copying Indy, however. In The Secret World, my character wields a whip. She found the whip by using a “time tomb”, called the “TARDIS”. She also has a fancy fedora hat. The other day, she wielded her whip, while wearing her hat, riding on a train to recover an ark. The ark, after all, belongs in a museum.

That quest was great fun, but the obvious ripoffness of at least three IPs got me thinking: how far can a game go in blatantly copying someone else? We all know how paranoid publishers can get about gamers copying games. So what gives with the double standards?

Copyright Symbol

Last fortnight I presented an argument that DRM leads to less abandonware. It was not well received. Yet just as I’ll always argue that Kelly is more attractive than Liara, I stand by every word I said.

Some commentators, though, made the point that DRM was actually taking away gamers’ rights under copyright. It was an interesting argument, so one I thought we’d discuss this week. As it turns out, the best argument against DRM is nothing to do with gamers’ rights, but that publishers themselves have enjoyed huge benefits from breaking DRM in the past.

Dune 2

Do you remember the Amiga? No? It was, for almost a good decade, the flag-bearer of the Glorious PC Master Race. The Amiga was competing with the NES, SNES, Master System, and Mega Drive—all at once. Against these consoles, the Commodore Amiga had the supreme gameplay, sound, and graphics capabilities, because Nintendon’t (I’m so clever).

Sadly, all good things must come to an end. Commodore made a series of downright stupid decisions, and lost their entire grip on the home PC market. Had it gone differently, you could have been reading this on the Amiga operating system Workbench, rather than Windows. Now, your only views to past greatness are Ebay, YouTube, and emulated abandonware.

This sums up why we need DRM quite nicely. Tis a tale of obsolete hardware, abandoned software, and very loose morals.

Steamy Money

Gamers are making half a million a year from selling game mods on the Steam Workshop. Not many, mind you, but just like the existence of aliens… it’s possible. Gabe Newell now wants to extend the concept to the Steam store itself.

Gabe sees Steam as just a boring old store, and wants to change it into a series of mini-stores, with games being sold in personal, individual stores created by gamers themselves. To be quite fair, he didn’t mention giving them any money, and right now, it’s just a pie in the sky.

But given the success of the Steam Workshop, could Steam actually become a store where gamers make money from selling games? “I’d buy stuff from Yahtzee”, says Gabe.

Wikipedia SOPA

With the United Nations getting ready to draft harsh internet censorship laws to prevent copyright infringement, Sega taking down fan videos left right and centre, and American lawmakers worried about counterfeit baby food harming American babies, the world of copyright is a scary place. Let our gaming lawyer Patrick Vuleta explain it all for you.

Legal Opinion: Which Games Should Get Government Money?

Did you see My Year Without Sex? No? C’mon, it was shown at the Adelaide Film Festival. Funded by Screen Australia?

No, of course you didn’t. It was a complete commercial flop.

On the other hand, you might have seen Saw. I didn’t—too squeamish. But it’s a successful film franchise that was denied Australian funding. So it was produced overseas.

Last week, the Federal Government announced the launch of a 20 million grant fund for Australian game developers. The guidelines for who gets these grants will be written by Screen Australia. Fortunately, Screen Australia has recognised that it mightn’t know a lot about funding successful games, and so has reached out to the games industry for input. So today, let’s look at how these grants should be funded.

Queensland R18

In a century a long time ago, far, far away—1922, to be precise, the Queensland senate voted itself out of existence. After several failed attempts to abolish the State’s upper house, our benevolent leader persuaded the Queensland Governor to hand his party a ruling majority, allowing him to abolish the senate.

And this is perfectly fine with most Queenslanders, who, without fail—vote overwhelming majorities into Parliament every election. We like our dictatorships.

So that’s why, today, we know the R18+ games legislation introduced to the Queensland Parliament a week ago, isn’t going to change. And it’s just as well, because out of all the R18+ laws… it actually makes sense.

Follow Games.on.net

Steam Group

Subscribe

Subscribe

Stay updated and get games.on.net delivered daily to your inbox!

Email:

Upcoming Games

Releasing Soon
Dead Island: Riptide Metro: Last Light Company of Heroes 2

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
Xbox One

Microsoft reveals the Xbox One: must go online once a day, will charge to play used games

Everything you need to know about Microsoft's announcement last night.

Path of Exile

Path of Exile launches an AU gateway: We talk to Grinding Gear about bandwidth costs, lag, and more

Bandwidth costs in Australia "over a hundred times more expensive" than other countries.

World of Warcraft

Building heroic scenarios, tweaking valor, and reduced XP: We talk to Blizzard’s Ion Hazzikostas about WoW 5.3

Why are Blizzard slashing the XP for the final five levels by 33%? Find out inside.

Anomaly 2

Anomaly 2 reviewed: Refreshingly clever strategy is back

The addition of multiplayer makes this twisted strategy title even better.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

The Regulars
Windows 8.1

Friday Tech Roundup (17 May 2013): Windows 8.1 is almost upon us

Plus, Google CEO says "don't be evil" was "stupid", and the $325,000 in-vitro burger.

Clive Barker's Jericho

Sitrep: A Troubled Romance with Clive Barker’s Jericho

Toby's guilty pleasure is this atrociously designed FPS.

Binary Domain

You Know What I Love? Rough Games

Brendan explains how sometimes it's better to try for something new than polish something old.

7GHz Haswell Processor

Friday Tech Roundup (10 May 2013): Would you like a 7GHz processor?

Plus quantum internet a reality, and the open-source gun controller.

Facebook Like Box

Friends of games.on.net