Rocksmith 2014 reviewed (PC): A finely tuned instrument

Rocksmith 2014

By on November 29, 2013 at 4:42 pm

To think it’s been more than a year since I reviewed the original Rocksmith. It’s not required reading, but if you’re interested in Rocksmith 2014, it’s probably not a bad idea to go back and read my review of the original since, in essence, it’s the same game and many aspects of the review will be a comparison between the two, with highlights of the changes. But let’s dive right in.

Rocksmith 2014  has done everything right. That’s the bottom, top and middle line. It’s taken everything I didn’t like about the original and added, modified or otherwise changed it until the game became an almost perfect iteration of the original Rocksmith. Almost perfect.

Alas, like with so many good things, when you fix one problem, others stem from the result. Take the song selection, for example. There is a far more varied and interesting song selection this time around, and 2014 allows you to import the songs from the original game, effectively doubling your setlist. Add the DLC on there and you have an official metric butt-tonne of songs.

Sounds great in theory (and in practice). But in theory, communism works. And so does this great list of songs. But with lots of songs comes lots of different tunings for your guitar to be in. Which means when you’re really getting into the swing of things you might find yourself having to stop and retune your guitar into Drop D, for example, only to have to tune it back after a single song. And then back to a different tuning after that.

I had debated whether to even mention this as a problem in this review, as there really isn’t anything that could be done — it’s part of the reality of a long and varied setlist. Ubisoft have helped out as much as they can, listing the tuning required for each song when you select it — so if you’re savvy to this, you can make your playlist entirely out of songs in a single tuning for your convenience. But it can be annoying.

As well as a better selection of songs, there is an entirely new mode of play as well. In the original Rocksmith there was the bass emulator, which meant you could learn some bass-ics (see what I did there?) on your regular six-string. This feature still exists, but as well as that, you can also choose between lead and rhythm guitar as well. This adds a whole new dimension to the experience, allowing you to learn either the upfront lead with the shreddy solos, or for you to take more of a support role with chords and the riffs that make up the backbone of the song.

In my review of the original Rocksmith I mentioned the Riff Repeater feature, a feature that was absolutely essential to nailing down any song. I also mentioned that it was tucked away under a multitude of menus. The Riff Repeater is still there, thankfully, but no longer tucked away. In fact, the path to learning a song is far easier than before.

When you select a song you’d like to learn in depth, the first screen you see has a series of checkboxes called “Rocksmith Recommends”. “Rocksmith Recommends” is a series of objectives that you can master in order to learn any song better. They might be as simple as, “Challenge yourself to beat your previous score” or as helpful as, “Learn this riff back to front and upside-down, dammit!”

The result is a more in-depth experience, as well as a more streamlined one, all at the same time. Learning a song has become about nailing the different elements, the chords required, the riffs you have trouble with; rather than just playing a song over and over. But these new elements are easily found and explored and Rocksmith learns from the way you play in order to recommend the next step that is best for you.

“Rocksmith Recommends” is also a larger set of missions designed to guide you through the experience with vague commands like, “Play a song in Drop D tuning,” or “Play a song from the 80s”. It’s totally ignorable if it’s not your thing, but if you’re looking for new things to try, it can usually point you in the right direction.

The only technical problem I’ve had with the game so far is a weird bug where the game slows down entirely. Not just the songs, but the whole game. The, uh, narrator even announces all the titles in sloooooo-mooooo, for example, and all the sound effects become distorted and slow.

This would normally be only a minor bump in the road requiring a restart of the game — annoying enough, but easily resolved. Unfortunately, like so many games lately, Rocksmith 2014 uses the dual Steam/uPlay system. With uPlay being as temperamental as it is, sometimes quitting the game means you won’t be able to re-launch it for whatever reason, meaning you’ll have to restart your whole system just for this one bug. It doesn’t happen often, but when it does, and you have to do a full reset, it’s enough to ragequit entirely.

On Ubisoft’s advice I changed from my sound card to my on-board sound, and that has seemed to fix the problem. Unfortunately, testing the fix is difficult because I’m waiting for something to not happen, so I’ll update the review if I find it hasn’t been effective after all.

Finally, my one piece of criticism in terms of the gameplay is with regard to the difficulty. I found, and I had other friends say the same, that the original game was pretty hard — because, I suppose, it is teaching you a real-life skill. It seems Ubisoft have heard this and modified the difficulty somewhat to make it more accessible.

The way the game ramps up the difficulty, though, is annoying. It needs to be… smarter, I suppose. Let me explain my problem: You choose a song to learn. It starts off pretty simple — maybe a little too simple, but it’s just getting started. Your notes are few and far between, which helps you get a handle on what the song is doing. You hit all the notes that come your way, so the game levels up your difficulty… just in time for the chorus.

Suddenly, you’re in a completely different part of the song, with different chords, but because you did SO good in that easy part, they’re coming at you a mile a minute, packed with tricky chords you can’t begin to wrap your fingers around. The difficulty needs to be more modular, perhaps. It needs to say, “Okay, you did great in this bit, so next time you play it, it will be harder. But this next bit is different and harder, so just try it on the lowest difficulty first.”

It sounds like a small thing, but the playability of the notes really is the essence of the game, and there were times when I had been plinking along just fine, only to be suddenly staring at the screen with my jaw on the floor as a rainbow of notes came whooshing at me. If I can’t play the notes, I can’t play the game. If I can’t play the game, I’ll never learn the guitar!

That said, however, Rocksmith 2014 is great. The series continues to impress and there are only a few hiccups left to be ironed out. Maybe Rocksmith 2015 will be absolutely perfect. But until then, Rocksmith 2014 is a solid continuation of the series. Even if you couldn’t get into the first one, I would give 2014 a shot, as it’s far more accessible to new players and advanced players alike.

Good:

  • Great list of songs, including songs from 2013
  • Improved Riff Repeater feature makes gradual learning easier
  • Rocksmith Recommends feature is great for getting into it
  • New lead and rhythm guitar capabilities

Bad:

  • Difficulty-adjusting could stand to be more intelligent
  • Possible bug with sound cards

Rocksmith 2014 is currently on sale on Steam for $37.46 until December 3 (normal price $49.95). The RealTone Cable necessary to play — and a guitar! — are not included.

You can also purchase the game from Uplay in a variety of editions, up to and including one with a guitar included. If all you need is a cable, you can buy that from Uplay here.

This review copy provided by Ubisoft. Screenshots used also provided by Ubisoft.

15 comments (Leave your own)

I got my first electric guitar this year and snapped up this as soon as i spotted it on steam. Loving it and really awesome for someone like me with zero musical experience. My only complaint is uplay :( i try to avoid other drm besides steam but its still worth it. also some fun musical games although im hopeless at them at the moment and have sore fingers as a result.

btw i think i bought my cable from jb hi fi online store if uplays is a pain

 

I couldn’t get into the original game for one reason: latency. Has that improved at all with RS2014? The original game was terrible on my PC, i tried absolutely everything i could think of to reduce it, ini tweaks, sound card settings, optical/analog inputs, I just couldn’t get it sorted. I have a proper I/O device for recording guitar (alesis io2) so I’m used to zero latency using ASIO drivers.

 

ok, i have been interested in this just for a bit of fun with friends, but i already have all the hardware and equipment i need to play guitar on computer (I use guitar rig). I would buy this game if i could use my own hardware and if i didn’t have to use the mess that is uplay.

 

i didnt really see it as a game. more a fun way to learn on own time. im not sure what you mean own hardware. you basically plug the cable into your guitar jack and the usb into pc. yeah it uses uplay one negative. but once loaded into the prog it didnt bother me.

i havent noticed any lag personally i havent had any probs. i agree with reviewer retunning has to be done often when changing songs but like stated you cant really see another option. it has to be done.

 

thats not C mixolydian…..

also the fact that ubi said to start using onboard sound is fucking stupid, when you use any DAW and have the power of individual sound card processing that helps bucketloads with latency, so they either coded it lazily or i dont know what, but onboard should never EVER beat a dedicated device, especially when it comes to in/out latency.

 

spike4379,

I don’t think it was a latency issue.

tranquil,

Yeah there’s a latency adjustment in the options this time around. I assume it works, but both RS games have worked perfectly out of the box for me so I haven’t played with it.

 

tranquil:
I couldn’t get into the original game for one reason: latency. Has that improved at all with RS2014? The original game was terrible on my PC, i tried absolutely everything i could think of to reduce it, ini tweaks, sound card settings, optical/analog inputs, I just couldn’t get it sorted. I have a proper I/O device for recording guitar (alesis io2) so I’m used to zero latency using ASIO drivers.

http://www.asio4all.com/

You are welcome :)…

 

Only thing that bothered me with the first was the lag between strumming and hearing what your playing , if they’ve fixed that this will be great , it’s an awesome tool if your learning.

 

bishopoz:
Only thing that bothered me with the first was the lag between strumming and hearing what your playing , if they’ve fixed that this will be great , it’s an awesome tool if your learning.

this is actually a big fuss in audio technology these days, the usual people to handle this are the ROLAND group with their shitty pickup with about 30ms lag.
fishman have made a wireless pickup that can be installed on any guitar and has a latency of about 5ms. though these problems dont exist on mac as windows has dodge audio coding in the OS.
so if ubisoft can comeup with a solution to guitar signal to usb to audio out thats pretty impressive in my books.

but seriously; HOW IS THAT C MIXOLYDIAN!??!

 

PinothyJ: http://www.asio4all.com/

You are welcome :)…

For what? Rocksmith doesn’t support ASIO lol. Not the last time i played it anyway.

 
 

It is C mixolydian. The strings are reversed compared to tab, Red Yellow Blue is E, A, D strings.

 

minkelz,

i realised after looking at it in that way, i cannot read it that way, my brain just cant do it after so many years of practice

 

spike4379,

There is an option to flip the strings so they are in tab order…

 

I have been hammering the game ever since it came out. I agree with most of the review but I think the reviewer should have played a bit longer before writing…
Firstly, you can set the initial difficulty you head in at – the game asks you when you first start what level of playing you are at and adjusts the starting difficulty of the songs to suit – it is also evaluating your abilities as you play and does ramp up the initial difficulty as you get better.

On the dynamic difficulty, yes it does ramp you up though the song when you play and you may get hit with something way out of your depth but don’t worry about that. All the songs are divided up into sections and the game keeps track of the difficulty for each section so it remembers that you didn’t do so well at the blazing solo and will drop the difficulty for that section but still hold you at a high level for the other bits you did well. It takes a few plays of a song before it homes in on a reasonable level for all the sections.

The review didn’t cover the “session mode” which is new in rs2014 and something that can be quite fun. In this mode you can put together a backing band of instruments played by AI agents, they listen to what you are doing with the guitar and try to match your playing… sort of a virtual jam. If you play hard, the speed up and get louder too, play slow and soft and they quieten down to match. The pics above with the instruments in them are from session mode. What is not shown/mentioned is that you can zoom out on the neck and it will show you all the positions on the whole neck for a particular scale so you can see at a glance that you can shift up to a different fret and know that you are still playing in the correct scale. Having a simple visual map of what notes are in scale is, in itself, a very handy learning aid. As well as that the game tells you when you are playing in tune with a scale – the root note letter (the letter in the circle) and the wavy lines either side go “fuzzy” if you hit a dissonant note, you can see that in the picture with the C mixolydian in it whereas the E blues picture is “clean” which indicates an in tune note.

Also – no mention of continuous play. You get to set up a play list of your favourite songs, set a time for how long you want to play and the game will randomly pick a set list from the play list you defined to fill the set time. I can see some people just using the game for this feature.

There was a touch on the riff repeater but, seriously, this was reworked to make it a truly valuable tool – not only is it right there when you play but you can select a section of song and repeat that until your fingers fall off – automatically incrementing the speed and/or difficulty when you start nailing the selected section (you can select the number of times you get the section right before it increments).

I am definitely hooked – I can play this game for 3 – 4 hours straight, some session mode, some learn a song and some continuous play.

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

YouTube

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
Destiny

Destiny is a Very Good Shooting Game, but in 2014, I want more

James comes away from Destiny impressed, but feeling like Bungie could have done a lot more.

Civilization: Beyond Earth

Sudden price rises for games just make everybody mad – so why do publishers keep doing it?

Pictured: Australians fighting against The Gigantic Price-Gouge Claw.

The Sims 4

The Sims 4 SteelSeries giveaway! Four prize packs up for grabs

Get your hands on some sim-ply excellent gear.

Batman Arkham Knight

Arkham Knight hands-on: Behind the wheel of the Batmobile

John takes the new Batmobile for a spin and comes away with a grin.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

Facebook Like Box