Batman: Arkham Origins reviewed (PC): The Batman game we need right now, but not the one we deserve

Batman: Arkham Origins

By on October 25, 2013 at 5:30 pm

Reviewer’s note: As multiplayer was not appropriately testable prior to release, we’ll address that in a separate article.

***

After the release of Arkham City, and with developer Rocksteady clearly at the top of their game, it was a little bit surprising to see Warner Bros. take Batman off them and hand it to their own internal studio at WB Montreal to pump out another one.

What’s not surprising — it turns out — is that when you hand a complete game engine and piles of game-ready assets to a developer and say “make another one of these”, you get… well, you get another Arkham game.

That’s what Arkham Origins is. That’s the bottom line, only I’m giving it to you at the top. Did you like Arkham City and Arkham Asylum? You will like Arkham Origins. If that’s all you care about, you can pretty much stop reading now.

Still with me? Good, because there’s more to it than that.

A reckless love

Arkham Origins was designed from the ground up to show a younger, more reckless Batman, and one quick to jump to the most violent solution possible. In fact this young Batman’s reliance on violence is actually a little bit distressing, and throughout the game he not only takes part in a number of unusually violent interrogations but even threatens to remotely access someone else’s pacemaker and send their heart into near-lethal overdrive.

(Origins doesn’t quite work in terms of timelines, because this Batman has all the gadgets — better gadgets, even — than the Batmen in Asylum and City do, and that doesn’t make sense because they take place after Orig- oh, whatever. Video games.)

It’s clearly a game made with love, by people who love Batman, and with a number of delightful hat-tips to the comics, which is good — because it would have been all too easy for a new developer like WB Montreal to get lost along the way trying to recreate what Rocksteady have done and end up with something that ultimately felt like a cash-grab. This is not the case here: this is a genuinely worthwhile addition to the Arkham franchise.

But welcome though this addition is, it has the unfortunate side effect of showing just how much work Rocksteady put into improving Arkham City over Arkham Asylum — and how little of that same drive WB Montreal have put into this.

All the Bat-ticks in all the Bat-boxes

A cynic might say that Arkham Origins feels and plays like Arkham City 2. They might point to the the fact that the world is almost entirely the same (filled with random groups of gangsters, with no civilians to be found, ever). They might point out how the city is absolutely stuffed with endless (excellent, but endless) amounts of side quests, crimes in progress, bonus content Riddler/Enigma things to collect, timed challenges, and so on.

They might point to the inclusion of the obligatory you-are-drugged-and-must-stumble-around scene. They might point to the scenes where you have to use the Batclaw to latch onto a hook and pull your little floating raft around (hnggghgh). They might point to the bomb countdowns where you have to race across the city. They might point to the scenes where you have to track a signal through the city by travelling in the direction of its highest wavelengths. They might point out how all the gadgets are the same, or how the animations are pretty much the same, or most of the upgrades are the same.

That cynic would be correct.

Now that doesn’t mean it’s a bad game — there’s a lot to be said for spit and polish (and holy PC gaming, Batman, did they ever polish it, as we’ll discuss later) but this is, very clearly, the result of a publisher directive: “Make another one of these popular Batman games, and don’t mess with it too much”. There are some new additions, but none of them are as sweeping as the change was from Asylum to City. This is iteration; not innovation.

New toys, new gadgets

Most of the improvements to the game come in the form of new things to play with. You can now drop smoke pellets when you’re under fire, which allows you to escape and reposition. There’s a concussion grenade to daze people from a distance, and the remote claw, which you’ll take off one of the eight assassins, is an awesome new toy that you can use to rope two enemies together Just Cause 2-styles, or use to drag an explosive barrel into a mook’s head from across the room. Between that and the new quick travel system which makes getting around the city a snap, it’s easier and more fun to be the post-pubescent half of the Dynamic Duo than ever before.

The biggest change is the much-hyped ‘Detective Mode’, which supposedly plays to the theme of the World’s Greatest Detective, but means that ultimately every mystery can be solved by playing the “find the red triangle” game. Detective Mode opens automatically when there’s a mystery to be solved, and finding and scanning the triangles reconstructs the crime scene for you. You then need to rewind forward and back until you spot the clue — helpfully pointed out by an unmissable glowing red line — which allows you to complete the mystery.

Frankly, the World’s Greatest Detective is really just the World’s Greatest Man-With-A-Sweet-Computer-On-His-Wrist, and there’s zero thinking or guesswork involved on the part of the player at all. It’s a great addition to the game and helps to build a lot of the atmosphere around the crime scenes, but it’s a huge missed opportunity to actually offer the player the chance to do even a little bit of puzzling or even, you know, feel like a detective for once.

Old faces, new places

WB Montreal have also done a bang-up job of re-inventing some of the older or more obscure DC villains into updated Arkham bad guys, with Firefly, Deadshot and Copperhead in particular being some of the best. The only problem with this approach is that the game starts to quickly feel like a rogue’s gallery of “hey-look-at-this”, which is something that is always going to be an issue with licensed properties, but using the more obscure villains instead of relying on the Big Hitters is a clever way to mititgate this effect.

Boss battles with those villains run the gamut from uninspired to excellent, with Deathstroke — who has been heavily built-up in all the pre-release marketing as a sort of evil counterpart to Batman — being notably disappointing, vomiting out some of the most insipid, cringeworthy dialogue as he moves slowly and carefully around. Sometimes the game throws you a genuine curveball too, like the battle with Electrocutioner which made me laugh in delight, but others feel somewhat crowbarred in and others are just genuinely boring such as the repetitive fights with Bane.

The story isn’t much to write home about, but it’s a real shame that the twist — if you can call it that — is painfully obvious and telegraphed about a mile away, with anybody able to put two and two together quickly coming up with four. I won’t spoil it for you here, but I was left feeling quite puzzled as to why it was meant to be such a big reveal when it happened. Additionally, by the end of the game the whole thing just feels worn out and overplayed. By the time the credits rolled I was just rolling my eyes at every cutscene and muttering “I get it! Yes, I get it already”. It’s just… it’s nothing new. And it doesn’t even care to try.

There’s a few neat additions in terms of locations, however, and things like being able to take the Batwing to the Batcave and Batwalk around talking to your Batbutler while you use the Batcomputer are Batgreat. Many of other locales you’ll explore are a nice mix of old and new, with Penguin’s very BioShock-esque ship and the GCPD in particular being standouts. There’s the obligatory sewer and warehouse levels, and Gotham’s inexplicable obsession with gargoyles in every large room is as handy as it ever was, but overall it’s a solid lineup.

The prettiest vigilante

If there’s one area of the game where WB Montreal deserve unequivocal applause, it’s in the graphics department: the PC edition of Origins is hugely impressive, and packed with enough rendering options to make anybody who thinks this is a lame console port weep in shame. From the way PhysX-powered papers and debris swirl around you as you move to the way footsteps appear in the snow, it’s a gorgeous piece of work and shows just how much effort has been put into improving the engine.

Cranking everything to max, I was still able to pull a good 70 frames per second out of Origins, but it was taking its toll on my machine which was putting out a lot of heat. Here’s a little video for you so you can see how it looks (download the video in HD from our file library here).

I’ve also had a chance to play with the PS3 version of the game, which just looks like a pile of bat droppings by comparison. WB Montreal haven’t messed with the keyboard controls either, which were perfect on PC for Arkham City and are just as good here, but the game does support the Xbox 360 controller if you’d prefer to play that way.

My only complaint is that the minimap is infuriatingly hard to navigate because you have to do it with WASD rather than just dragging to pan with the mouse, and lining up the cursor perfectly on a tiny icon of the Batwing so you can fast-travel is utterly, utterly infuriating. No such issues with a controller, natch.

The problem with making the game look so good is that it actually looks better than the pre-rendered cutscenes, which means that every time the game activates a cutscene the screen goes blurry and drops down to 720p. It’s a relief to go back to the beautifully crisp, high-detail game models, and it’s a shame that the cutscenes aren’t delivered in full HD (although with an install footprint of 18 GB, that’s probably for the best).

You have eaten well

There’s something of a parallel in the young studio of WB Montreal taking on the story of a young, inexperienced Batman, but where the young Batman is reckless and brash, WB are almost frighteningly safe and conservative.

Arkham Origins is littered with missed opportunities — from the same empty world of Gotham populated exclusively by angry criminals in masks, to the same lazy solution of “pour more bad guys into the room every time a cutscene ends”. The infiltration of the GCPD is a perfect example of this — rather than mixing it up by creating an environment of forced stealth, tripwires and alarms, they simply opted to make it a case of Batman almost casually strolling through the station and just punching cops in the face.

The cops are all corrupt of course, which makes them interchangeable with bad guys and so it’s okay to have a big brawl with them, and then the prisoners get out, and you have to fight them too, and then fight some more cops, and you know, despite how stunningly fluid the animation is, and despite the fact that the combat is better than ever, it’s all just a bit disappointing.

Origins is a superb game, and great fun to play, and will make every Batman fan very happy — but if WB make another Arkham game, and chances are they probably will — it will need to be a lot braver than this. I don’t know if people will want to play Arkham City for a third time when 2015 rolls around.

Good:

  • It’s basically Arkham City 2
  • Same great Arkham City gameplay, only with more gadgets and more stuff to do
  • Good cast of characters, stays away from the ground trod by the previous two games
  • Looks genuinely great on PC, large range of graphics options
  • More areas to explore
  • The violent, reckless young Batman is handled well

Bad:

  • It’s basically Arkham City 2
  • Dialogue is really quite bad
  • Heaps of missed opportunities to actually do something new and interesting
  • The much-hyped Detective Mode is just for show
  • Pre-rendered cutscenes look worse than actual game
  • Some very bad checkpointing

Batman: Arkham Origins is available from Green Man Gaming for $50, or a ridiculously good value $37 if you use the code GMG25-GRV7N-YY833 before 11:59PM AEDT on tonight, Friday 25 October.

This review code supplied by Warner Bros. Screenshots used in the review taken by the reviewer.

22 comments (Leave your own)

“Pre-rendered cutscenes look worse than actual game”

The fact that we’ve gotten to the stage in gaming where this happens fills me with all kinds of happy feelings.

 

As Ive only played multiplayer, i cant comment at all on the sp. However Splash Damages MP component is worthy and a lot of fun. Ive used batman, bane, and ranked up to level 8, got some bane goon gadgets going. EDIT: there also seems to be little to no lag in the games Ive played, (bigpond ultimate cable) but Im not sure as to whether they are aussie hosts (the game has no dedicated servers unfortunately)

Please note that with all the amazing graphic options there ISNT a FOV slider for those affected by such things. I dont suffer from it, so im unfazed. The game looks gorgeous. Absolutely stunning.

My rig is an i7 4770, 16 gig of ram, windows 8.1, and a GTX670. i get around 70 FPS.

I own batman asylum and city, but i havent played either, got them on special, i think it might be hard to go back and play them after playing origins?

 

Sounds like a good purchase, but also sounds like I’ll have the same dislikes I had with city. But! I shall play tonight and find out :D

 

Awesome, tbh I don’t care if its the same as City because I loved that game and played it through twice (although I only did all of the riddler puzzles once), and I played through Asylum probably 3 or 4 times. Great series, my all time favourite.

I’m stoked!!

L

 

How much worse are the PS3 graphics? I’ve always played the Arkham series on my PS3 as I liked to sit back on the recliner couch in my home theatre room and mash away on the buttons.

I could plug my xbox controller into the PC, but I kinda like the continuity…

 

ralphwiggum: How much worse are the PS3 graphics?

They’re basically just as good as they were in Arkham City, if not slightly better, so you’ll be fine :)

It’s just that they look really poor by comparison — shadows are really fuzzy, draw distance much lower, that sort of thing.

 

Cheers for that Tim. I’ll have to think on it a bit more. The graphics don’t bother me so much (kinda expected it) though the other thing is that I can pick up a PC version for $35-$40 whereas a PS3 version is like $60-$70….

 

Sir giggles, the story is prequel, asylum is more straight not as open but a great game, the combat is not as good but still good. City is amazing and from other reviews read a tighter and better game. It is definitely worth playing them.

 

Actually I’m of the opinion both Asylum and City are superior to this title. Not 100% sure why but the combat feels less satisfying this time around, plus it seems content to throw more of it at you. I’ve only sunk in close to 2 hours into it though, might sink a few more hours into it tomorrow, but from current perspective, it feels like a game I’ll have to force myself to finish. It will be a bad thing for this game if another game pops its head up…

That said it’s not a bad game. It’s just not…grabbing me quite yet.

Oh and another thing seems to bug me is the interface. I’ve just come off Arkham Asylum where you tap q to quick batarang throw, to this one where it’s tap 1 twice? Also dragging around the map with the mouse – you can’t do it in Origins. What gives? Also clicking on the separate tabs (ie map, Waynetech, etc tabs) doesn’t seem to do anything, you have to press the Q and E keys to cycle between them. Who designed this interface?

 

vcatkiller,

The double tap was like that in City. Double tap the corisponding number to quick use that item. It worked for the batarang, claw, explosive, electro-shock, frost grenade, and some others if I missed them.

My copy is still downloading…

 

vcatkiller: Also dragging around the map with the mouse – you can’t do it in Origins. What gives? Also clicking on the separate tabs (ie map, Waynetech, etc tabs) doesn’t seem to do anything, you have to press the Q and E keys to cycle between them. Who designed this interface?

Yep, the map interface is super terrible, isn’t it. I don’t know how they could have such expertise to put together such an impressive overhaul to the graphics engine and then go: “Nobody would ever want to use the MOUSE on the map screen, right?”

 

Holy gosh yes, the UI is awful to navigate with a mouse, totally crazy.

Couple of hours in now, it’s fun, but as Tim says in his review, more of the same for the most part.

 

$25 from cdkeysdirect.com
Took until seeing that to justify the purchase to myself. Worth it :)

 

$22.50AU cdkeyport steam key. so cheap for a new game but I’m not sure I’ll play it. Still got Crysis 3 and farcry 3 to finish and BF4 only a few days away.

Price is very tempting though.

 

It might be worth holding off a little, see if they release a patch. After running into a bug in Burnley tower which lets you in but won’t let you out I tracked over to the steam forums and found this isn’t the only fun players have been encountering.

http://steamcommunity.com/app/209000/discussions/0/792924952554932514/

 

vcatkiller,

I had that in penguins area, restarting the game fixed it though, so wasn’t game breaking for me.

 
MuscularTeeth

ha i crawled in a gap in the penguins ship and was walking above all the rooms. i managed to do a jumpy roll thing and fell off the map and kept falling for ever until i restarted.
apart from that; ui feels not as nice as other games – but im pretending cos its an earlier OS batman is using.
still enjoying it, and using an xbox controller for the game is more enjoyable.

 

makena,

Yeah but I don’t want to have to restart every time a bug creeps up, just in case it might fix the problem. It’s frustrating enough as it is without having to replay areas over and over again…

 

vcatkiller: After running into a bug in Burnley tower which lets you in but won’t let you out

Huh, this happened to me as well, but I figured I was just dumb and hadn’t figured it out yet. There you go.

That’s the only bug I’ve seen so far though. I’ve heard reports of some people getting hard lockups but nothing on my end.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkDLaojdCCw&feature=youtu.be

A method to glitch pass the bugged air vent in Burnley Tower.

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Releasing Soon
Thief Shadowrun Returns South Park: The Stick of Truth

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
heroes_of_the_storm

Heroes of the Storm: Blizzard’s Dustin Browder on rage problems, hybrid roles, and balance

"We’re trying to make it so if there’s something obvious that you want to do, it’s the right thing to do. There’s no sort of hidden rules or hidden strategies that make that wrong."

ArcheAge

ArcheAge’s alpha impressions: The freeform Korean MMO that might just live up to its promises

This high-flying Korean MMO has finally made it to a Western release. James jumps in to see if the promise 'sandpark' model delivers.

Reaper of Souls

Diablo 3: Reaper of Souls reviewed: Change is a good thing

Blizzard shows that it isn't afraid to change everything

Titanfall

Titanfall: Crush your enemies under your robotic foot with these gameplay tips

Wallrunning speed boosts, room clearing strategies, and more inside.

Diablo 3 Competition

Diablo 3: Reaper of Souls Giveaway – The Winners!

You cannot kill Death -- unless you have sick new gear.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

The Regulars
The Secret World

Legal Opinion: Bait and switch… with a mankini

Not everybody is laughing following Funcom's April Fools joke on its players.

Bad at Aiming

Sitrep: Waiting in line at the FPS dole queue

Toby is so incompetent that he needs an entire new genre of games invented just to cater for him.

Amazon Fire

Friday Tech Roundup (04 April 2014): Radeon R9 295X2 specs leak

Also, the man behind the "Microsoft" phone scam has been captured and fined.

Barrett M98B

Legal Opinion: Where does your money go?

Why do games cost so much to manufacture? Because everybody wants a slice of that licensing pie.

Facebook Like Box