The Bureau: XCOM Declassified reviewed – Identity Unknown

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified

By on August 22, 2013 at 3:57 pm

X-COM was once one of those sacred properties that would live on, forever, in the minds of those lucky enough to have experienced them in their original glory. Arguably one of the best turn-based strategy titles ever made, X-COM: UFO Defence redefined how players managed not only a squad, or a mission, but an entire counter-attack against invading aliens. Balancing resources and making the tough decisions about which parts of Earth to save or leave to rot was not only an unrelentingly stressful and difficult task, but immensely satisfying when it all came together.

The recent remake of this classic, Enemy Unknown, had its problems but succeeded (get our review here) in understanding what elements made the original so addictive and enjoyable, while adding a 3D perspective and modifying behavior to allow for a new system of cover and squad manipulation.

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified began its life as the “original” re-imagining — an FPS where you would take on the form of an individual squad member or commander (ala Syndicate) and fight through the invasion at ground level with the ability to pause and modify squad placement from the top down. From the moment it was announced,  the title was forced to rush through a plethora of various forms and imaginings, ditching its isometric roots to compete on the same level as other shooters. Terms like “survival horror” were bandied around, to the (actual) horror of many X-COM devotees, along with a host of promises to preserve elements like squad and base control.

Eventually, the FPS idea was dropped after an uproar from the community (and critics) and instead morphed into a third person, over the shoulder shooter which essentially is much of what they promised — just from a different perspective.

The game is set in the 60′s, and opens with an alien attack on a major military facility where you, Special Agent William Carter, are awaiting orders to deliver a mysterious suitcase to a mysterious gentleman. Before long, you’re part of “The Bureau”, originally set up to defend the US from Soviet attack, but quickly retrofitted to becoming the final stand against the invasion. It’s from here that the bulk of the game is played — from researching new technologies, chatting to various people about various world ending topics, to choosing which part of the United States you’d like to visit and blow away aliens in.

It’s here you can see that 2K Marin have nailed the aesthetic. Everything looks sufficiently part of the Kennedy era, from the WW2 rifles to the various “Home Town USA” locales you’ll find yourself in. Everything down to the voices, clothes and makeup of the various characters replicates the paranoid antics of Cold War era America. The problem lies in that claustrophobic element of being actually stuck within the XCOM base.

In the original game you flew above the base, quickly accessing various areas to upgrade tech or sort out your squad. Deploying was just a couple of clicks away. On base (and in person) you’ll find yourself walking (more like meandering, really) around the various sections of XCOM, having largely useless conversations about pointless babble in order to proceed to the next mission. Those keen on Bioshock style diaries will find them littered around the place to pick up or listen to — from notes to recordings — which lets you uncover untold parts of the story, but generally you’ll end up frustrated that getting everything done is so laborious. It’s surprising, and a little confounding — especially since accessing the same functions when you are out on a mission is much simpler, as are the mechanics of play, that you wonder why the base wasn’t just a couple of menus or a top down area in the first place.

The Bureau, ultimately, aspires to be too many different things. When you’re out in the field, it’s XCOM at the coal face. You control your squad via an intuitive full screen menu that pops up when you hit the spacebar and allows you to quickly provide orders to your squadmates, from dropping mines to placing them behind new cover. When the system works, it works well — it’s easy to jump in and out of active combat to set up a flanking maneuver or to set up a combo attack of various abilities in perfect synchronization.  But when it doesn’t (which is more often than not) you’ll be yelling at the confounding stupidity of your AI controlled squaddies as they attempt to get themselves killed in the most moronic ways possible.

Sometimes, they’ll run directly through a group of trigger happy enemies, instead of carefully around heavy cover. They’ll run out into an area to drop a mine, instead of lobbing it from a safe spot behind cover. Other times they’ll simply blind fire at a gun turret.

I found myself micro-managing almost every movement, hitting space after each successful attack to reposition or re-target their aim, or simply hitting F2 to bring them back to my position. Leaving them alone during the ability recharge period was far too dicey: in most cases they would sit and absorb fire until they become incapacitated, leaving me or the alternative squadmate to revive them. Thankfully, during the revival process you are actually invulnerable to attack, meaning it was almost impossible to die unless you were supremely incompetent. It’s like the developers were well aware of how useless your team were without you shepherding their every action, and took pity on you as you struggled to move your clumsy arse in and out of cover while your men (there are no women) flipped and flopped around the battlefield like dying fish on the hull of your dads dinghy.

It’s a shame too, because parts of the combat can be a lot of fun, especially when you level up enough to have pretty fun abilities such as lifting up dudes from behind cover for easy shots, or dropping laser turrets for protection against flanking. There’s a host of traditional XCOM weaponry on offer, plus the custom upgrade packs and perks to bolster your teams effectiveness. You can name your squad (a feature that is one of my personal XCOM favourites) and create new agents for your roster.  Later on in the game there are also a couple of outstanding missions that make much of the AI frustrations somewhat forgettable, but combat still tends to favour the waves of drop-podded enemies with the odd elite here and there. This in itself isn’t a bad thing, and frankly, XCOM was just a bunch of enemies on a map you needed to kill, so I can’t pretend like I didn’t enjoy it — at least those times when I wasn’t having to constantly stop my teammates from running across landmines.

The Bureau draws heavily from Mass Effect. Unfortunately, while it stole a lot of the elements that made it interesting, it failed to keep the controls tight and responsive, or make the story interesting and deep, or gift you with AI squadmates intelligent enough to keep themselves alive during a firefight. Even the dialogue trees are ripped straight out of BioWare’s playbook, offering you various wheel-based options for responses alongside a number of choices at various avenues. But I just wasn’t feeling it — during combat missions the story is communicated through cutscenes without a whole lot of subtlety. The voice acting is okay, but the animations are in many cases broken (one NPC just stared at the ceiling while he talked to me) and at other times I found the lip-syncing way off. On top of that, the plot is just plain boring, uninspiring and relies too much on tropes. I won’t spoil it, but the whole Roswell thing just doesn’t cut it any more.

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified is, unfortunately, another casualty of a development hell project with just too many flaws to recommend. Sure, there’s a lot of fun action to be had. But there’s also far too much filler stuffed in and around the fun parts. If I were you, I’d sit out on this particular assignment, especially if you’re an X-COM diehard.

Good:

  • Great presentation, atmosphere and aesthics
  • Intense, XCOM inspired third person combat

Bad:

  • Poor AI lets down much of the strategic elements
  • A boring story with generic, uninspiring protagonists
  • Missing some polish around voice acting, animations and graphics quality
  • Didn’t really need the XCOM name at all

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified is available on Steam as of tomorrow for $79.99.

This review copy supplied by the publisher.

18 comments (Leave your own)

NNOOOOOOOOOOo I preordered this :(

How could they do this :(

 
CaptainCleanoff

Meh, something told me this was going to be one to skip…

Aliens CM has taught me some very important lessons.

 

Guess I’ll find out how bad it is tomorrow

 
Bane Williams

captaincleanoff,

Aliens CM taught you some very important lessons? You didn’t learn them in the number of games prior to that which have a similar fate? :P

I’m teasing. I both enjoy and hate this game in about equal measure.

 

Sounds like it could do with some 3 player co-op to make things a bit more fun. I played Resident Evil 5 out of the gate with a friend and had a ball. This sounds the same in some ways regarding the AI.

 

I was really looking forward to their original idea and plan for X-com. It looked original at least. didn’t look like it had too much mambo-jumbo tech in it either. oh well…

 
CaptainCleanoff

Bane Williams,

I guess what I could say is that ACM reinforced what I already knew, but failed to act on. ;)

 

destructoid gave this 2/5, she did not like it at all

 

Looks interesting enough to grab for the right price, at least according to a few reviews. Why is the (fairly unreasonable) price asked by the publisher not mentioned in the review? Surely if it was a $10 job, rather than a AAA price, it would chang the perspective?

James Pinnell: the whole Roswell thing just doesn’t cut it any more.

It’s rather funny you should say that (in such an objective way too) since a bunch of Area 51 documents have just been declassified. I would say that’s pretty relevant, albeit by absolute luck. I don’t actually recall ever playing a game about the supposed (or real) activity in Roswell, so I’ll take your opinion on the story with a grain of salt.

Oh wait…. the only one I can think of is Deus Ex. I suppose that game also has a rubbish plot?

 
James Pinnell

ooshp:

Oh wait…. the only one I can think of is Deus Ex. I suppose that game also has a rubbish plot?

That’s a pretty ridiculous stretch of the imagination to take. This game’s story and overarching plot line is nowhere near as nuanced and deep as Deus Ex’s, nor is it delivered as creatively.

It’s totally up to you whether you take my opinion on the story seriously or not, but judging from other reviews I’ve read since I completed mine (I don’t read others until I’ve finished my own) I’m not the only one who was disappointed with the delivery or the content.

Re: Price: Generally I don’t factor price into games unless its very low ($20 or less) and the title obviously suffers from a tiny budget. If that’s the case I will give it a bit of grace, especially if the developer is independent. That said, engines like Unity are very cheap and can produce fantastic results for low investment – but that’s a discussion for another article ;)

The game is priced no different to a bunch of other AAA titles the site has reviewed as of late, and its an unfortunately consequence of the publisher’s (2K is hardly the only suspect here) continued campaign of charging Australians more for the same software. As much as this riles me, the developer does not set the price of their software and shouldn’t be punished for that.

In any case, our sponsor Green Man Gaming is selling it for $34 less than the RRP, and other sites are even cheaper in some cases. I think our readers are savvy enough to shop around.

 

I have played the first mission, and then tried the second… NEEDS work… Also, mouse and keyboard feels REALLY awkward to use. Hopefully patches will fix it.

Am glad I preodered from GoGo and not Steam. Only dropped 40 on this instead of 80. lol

 

As a massive orig xcom fun, caused me to fail year 8 … Im disappointed but will add to my steam sale get list still, maybe give it a few patches.

 

James Pinnell: As much as this riles me, the developer does not set the price of their software and shouldn’t be punished for that.

True, the price is sometimes out of the developers’ control, but I still think it should be considered. If a publisher decides a game needs to be launched before it’s ready, does a review not reflect the state of the game, regardless of the fact that it’s the publishers ‘fault’?

Not that I usually watch Good Game, but their review of Rise of the Triad failed to mention that the game is only $15, and they gave it a bashing (personally I think they completely missed the point of the game). In the same episode they heaped praise on Disney Infinity which is apparently over $400 if you want all the launch content. The publisher’s idea of the game’s value is almost the only objective aspect a review can look at, so I don’t think it should be overlooked.

edit – I’m going to buy this game and enjoy the story just to spite you

 

Eh. Xcom games always had dull story.
Gameplay is why we love Xcom.
Might be why we hate this one too so…

Still getting it.

 
James Pinnell

ooshp
edit – I’m going to buy this game and enjoy the story just to spite you

Is that a /s? I wouldn’t be offended in the slightest if you enjoyed the game at all – power to you. Steve (Bajo from GG) is a friend of mine – he told me during a discussion on this that he actually enjoyed the game. While I disagree with him on a few points (he agrees with a lot of mine too) I don’t have a problem with people disagreeing with my opinion.

 

Hate to say “I told you so”.

Pretty much every alarm bell in my head was ringing “Generic 3rd person shooter leeching off a much better franchise’s good name” when I first saw this. It would be far from the first time the XCOM has been been abused either.

I was honestly hoping I was completely wrong on this but yeah… Let’s just say I am glad I held off on running out and pre-ordering it.

 

Had a quick go of it today. Using an XBox360 controller probably wasn’t the best way to play the game.

Will give it a serious grind over the weekend. First impression is that it doesn’t look bad, though the Bioshock-type aesthetic looks more like an artistic signature than something that fits the game.

 
NoobyMcNoobnoob

just started it, enjoying it a fair bit, cept the main faces and animations on the women look like there gonna peel the skin off and be reptiles or robots from westworld movie underneath

plus all the old xcom games cause i preorder off steam was defiantly worth it

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

YouTube

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
Dragon Age Inquistion

I Hope There Aren’t Any Straight Characters in Dragon Age: Inquisition

I'm no bigot, but I have to get this off my chest.

Divinity: Original Sin

Dungeons & Divinity: Why co-op Original Sin is just like a great game of D&D

This is one game that lovers of co-op and lovers of tabletop should not be missing out on.

civilization_beyond_earth_5

Why doesn’t Civilization: Beyond Earth look more alien? We ask Firaxis

Humans have some hard-wiring which is really difficult to get around, it turns out.

Wasteland 2

Chris Avellone talks RPG design, why new games are too hand-holding, and more

One of the biggest names in RPG design chats to us about what makes a game great.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

Facebook Like Box