Dungeonland reviewed: A great idea with some poor, frustrating execution

Dungeonland

By on February 7, 2013 at 2:47 pm

Know what makes a great party game? Action RPGs like Diablo. You get to run around with friends, blowing up monsters and collecting sweet loot. They can be really hard, but often they reward you so frequently that every little roadblock gives you the chance to pick up some amazing new mace or helmet.

Know what else works well with some pals? Those LEGO movie-themed games. They’re simple, colourful, easy, and relatively brainless.

Where the two meet, you’ll find Dungeonland, a co-operative hack-n-slash that feels a little like Diablo burst through the seven layers of Hell and found only the colourful, simplified world of the LEGO games. Except things aren’t made of blocks, and… well, it’s not actually anywhere near as fun as that sounds.

Mechanically, Dungeonland sounds great on paper. There are three character classes – the Mage, Rogue and Warrior – and each has two special skills, a basic attack, and panic-button ability. The special skills can combine across classes to some extent to provide a well coordinated team an extra layer of potency. The skills, along with several passive things, can be tweaked via an in-game shop to change your style of play, too. You can be a hugely aggressive, in-your-face Rogue, or you can step back and be a little daintier, attacking from range and even dropping a barrel of potions for your injured friends-Rogue.

Sounds cool so far, but unfortunately a lot of the core skills – such as the Mage’s Ray of Awesome, which makes a target ally invulnerable for as long as you can keep casting it – are extremely passive. You cast it, and you can do nothing else but run around for as long as you want to keep it up. The Warrior has a passive shield-thing which makes him invulnerable too, and the same limitations apply. This means that playing as an effective team often means running around doing no damage but trying to keep a foe’s attention while your Rogue friend tries desperately to make up for all the damage you’re not doing.

Dungeonland is very much built for a coordinated team. If you don’t have some friends you play with regularly, you’re not likely to get very far. Dungeonland’s cartoony visuals mask very challenging gameplay. There are some AI-controlled bots, but even on the simplest difficulty they flounder uselessly. And unfortunately, you really need them to stay alive.

Failure is measured by a shared pool of lives. If an ally collapses and you can’t revive them in time, your entire team loses a life. If you’re out of lives and other ally dies, it’s game over. Even if you and the other ally are in perfect health. And when that happens, regardless of how far through the dungeon you were, it’s all over. You gotta start again.

There are three dungeon-styles currently available, all of which ooze personality and play on fantasy and theme-park tropes wonderfully, and a Dungeon Maestro mode, which is far and away Dungeonland‘s highlight. Rather than fight trolls on the battlefield, Dungeon Maestro gives you a birds-eye view of the dungeon, and the ability to place traps, spawn monsters and generally screw over the players in the dungeon. It’s hugely fun, but not especially well-tuned. It’s typically super easy to wipe out three players in a few short minutes, even on one of the lower difficulty levels. Dungeonland does not favour players in the actual dungeons.

There are lots of unlockables, both aesthetic and functional. In particular, each class has a couple unlockable variants, and most of the best stuff for Dungeon Maestro mode is locked behind a stack of coins (which you can actually earn quite easily). But given the overly-passive and often overly-punishing nature of Dungeonland, it may not hold your interest long enough for you to bother.

Good:

  • Loaded with personality.
  • Dungeon Maestro mode makes ruining friendships a blast.

Bad:

  • Skills feel very passive and unheroic.
  • Very punishing, especially when you’re playing solo.

Our review copy of Dungeonland generously provided by Green Man Gaming, where you can buy Dungeonland for a mere $9.99. Thanks, GMG!

We have four copies of Dungeonland to give away in a secret competition! To enter, leave a comment on this article that uses the words ‘Ray of Awesome’ somewhere inside. We’ll pick four winners at random at midnight tonight and send them PMs with their game codes. Tee hee!

Tags:
20 comments (Leave your own)

Its a shame this game was only partially singed with the Ray of Awesome.

 

By your text (“passive” skills?) and screenshots (only first area, and only bots), it`s likely that you didn’t learn how to play the game, and did not play with friends – you certainly did not complete it in the easiest difficulty setting…

 

trapwire:
By your text (“passive” skills?) and screenshots (only first area, and only bots), it`s likely that you didn’t learn how to play the game, and did not play with friends – you certainly did not complete it in the easiest difficulty setting…

Go on…

 

This sounded so interesting in previews. Hope it is touched by the Ray of Awesome rather than the Ray of Suck.

 

I do so enjoy screwing around with the players…

 

So I need an ar Ray of Awesome friends to play this game? SOL :(

 
Thermal Ions

This was looking really promising, however the Ray of Awesome expectation I had has turned to an overcast drizzle of disappointment.

While I’ve friends I could play the game with, thus minimising the exposure to the AI, the imbalance I’ve seen in videos and reviews has dropped the game down into the bottom of my discounted bargain price wishlist. It’s particularly worrisome given there’s been no indication that I’ve seen from the devs which indicate they acknowledge it could do with some tweaking.

 

I’ve watched a fair few gameplay videos (One involving dev members, where they really knew how to use that Ray of Awesome) and dungeon master mode seems like the best part, at least in my opinion. I wonder if they have the ability to DM against bots?

 

It sounds like one of the only good Ray of Awesome would be within modding potential, if it existed.

 

hopefully the ‘Ray of Awesome’ like passive skills arent as un-fun as they sound, I had been hoping to give this a go, but It sounds a bit weak :/

 

Hrrm, maybe I need to make my own game, with a Ray of Awesomeness, and black jack, and hookers.

 

They also accidentally released the OS X client which doesn’t work and looks like it wont work for a while.

 

Ray of awesome, ray of awesome… ray of awesome.

Awesome, Ray of.

 

Watching TotalBiscuit lay the smackdown on his wife, Dodger and Jesse was a little Ray of Awesome. It’d be fun to recreate that with some friends …

GUY HEROOOOOOO!!!

 

I cast Ray Of Awesome… at the darkness, hehehe

I mostly prefer to solo games like this, my friends and I lack…. coordination ;)

 

I think more games need a Ray of Awesome, maybe an online partition is needed? Anyway here is a Ray of Awesome for the competition.

 

Could somebody please help me out? I’m trying to remember the name of a game slightly similar to this but for the life of me can’t!

It was a game I read about and watched a trailer for late last year, where you had a hero and built your own castle dungeon master style, and other online players tried to fight through with their heroes to get to your loot, and in turn you could raid other castles.

Any Ideas?
Cheers in advance!

EDIT – Found it, “The Mighty Quest for Epic Loot” thanks anyway guys.

 

Thanks to everybody who entered our secret little competition! I’ve PM’d you your codes. Enjoy!

 

So I’m too late to use the Ray of Awesome?

 

I’m sorry, yes!

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

YouTube

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
The Evil Within

The Evil Within: It’s a fine line between pleasure and pain (especially on PC)

We check out Shinji Mikami's latest punishment simulator, but buyer beware when it comes to the PC version.

Shadow of Mordor

Choose your own adventure: Why heavily scripted cinematic games need to loosen up

It's time for game developers to sit back and let the players take control.

world of warcraft warlords of draenor

World of Warcraft’s Tom Chilton talks Warlords, paid level 90 boosts, and jumping the shark

WoW's Game Director explains how they've been on, off, and all around the shark since 2004.

Shadow of Mordor

Shadow of Mordor isn’t just a pretty good LotR game: it’s open-world stealth-action done right

What looked to be a phoned-in LotR cashgrab turns out to be one of the most engaging pieces of interesting, systemic design in recent years.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

Facebook Like Box