Planetside 2 reviewed: A dangerously addictive MMOFPS that won’t break the bank

PlanetSide 2

By on November 22, 2012 at 1:48 pm

I’ve always wondered why MMOFPS titles have never truly taken off, or at least to the extent that their step-parents (Battlefield and Call of Duty) have. The original PlanetSide eventually spawned a sort of cult following, but never managed (possibly due to the subscription fee structure) to grow a base of significant popularity. There have been games since, such as Sony’s MAG on the PS3, that attempted to create large battlefields along with the illusion of persistent cause and effect, but nothing had managed to reach the lofty aspirations of wide constant conflict.

PlanetSide 2 hopes to change the fortunes of the IP, namely by removing the largest barrier to entry (upfront and ongoing costs), overhauling the engine, and re-working much of the advancement, deployment and certification systems to invite a new generation of players who grew up with modern shooters. But have SOE prevailed where many of their other properties have failed?

For those unaware of the original PlanetSide, battle takes place across one of a few sprawling conquest-style maps, where players align themselves with one of three colours empires (each with various traits) and fight to capture the facilities across the landscape. Capturing certain areas opens up tactical possibilities, including both infantry and vehicle spawn points for both air and ground assets, resources (Aerospace, Mechanized, and Infantry, more on these later), regrouping for assaults and so forth. The aim is, as you would imagine, to dominate your enemy through a combination of clever tactical manoeuvres (such as grabbing a dropship of 12 soldiers and flanking across enemy lines) and sheer brute force. Dropships can also be used as mobile spawn points, and in some cases, you are able to use the “Instant Action” feature to drop from space onto flash points directly.

Players can choose one of five classes; a light or heavy assault class, a medic, a infiltrator (scout) and engineer. Each class can be heavily customized and upgraded via the certification system by spending certification points, gained via time spent in game or through XP generation, to purchase upgrades. One change that PS1 veterans may notice is that there is no longer a limit to point generation — this is essentially to both reward continued play but also to allow for levelling of multiple classes on the same soldier. As someone who got a little tired of being typecast as a heavy in the original, this is a welcome change.

One of the biggest assets PlanetSide 2 had from its inception to its recent launch is John Smedley, the president of SOE and one of the most open and passionate advocates I’ve seen

Resources are split between various territories and are vital components for your equipment, from vehicles to items, and an empire’s lack of a certain resource can restrict the availability of that tool. What this attempts to do is force players to identify which resources are required and to capture facilities that are generating them. I really like the idea but in practice it’s a little bit messy. This could be entirely due to the lack of experienced players certified in senior positions, to help co-ordinate units and squads to fill gaps and silo materials. At the very least, it provides more of a concrete incentive to choose a certain area over another and allows squads to make “hero” plays by single-handedly capturing important supply routes for their empires.

One of the biggest assets PlanetSide 2 had from its inception to its recent launch is John Smedley, the president of SOE and one of the most open and passionate advocates I’ve seen for a title in a very long time. It’s obvious from his almost 24hr presence on social networks, countless interviews and weekly blog posts that there is a lot riding on the success of this title, particularly after the costly, mistake ridden and high profile failure of DC Universe Online.

SOE’s subsequent attempts to revitalise its entire suite of MMOs via “Play Your Way”, a universal F2P monetisation structure, has begun to gradually change its fortunes, with titles originally struggling to turn a dollar reporting dramatic increases in revenue. PlanetSide 2 is the first new title to be designed entirely around this concept, relying on the idea that players will be willing to fork over some cash to streamline or speed up their soldiers development.

It’s arguably the biggest change, conceptually, to the game but the developers have been very careful to ensure that it doesn’t perversely affect the game’s balance. The large majority of paid advantage comes in the form of boosts, from XP gain to passive certification growth. Paid members get no more than a 50% boost to any of these properties, with the exception of resource gain, which is 100%, in the form of being able to spawn an extra vehicle if the pool happens to be tapped out. Additionally, while weapon and ability unlocks can be purchased (with Station Points), many of these abilities tend to be more in the form of “sidegrades”, providing no absolute advantage (the weapon is no more powerful from a damage perspective than any other) but may offer a different way to play a class.

After playing for quite a long time during both open and closed beta, and for the last few days during retail, it’s clear that SOE have thought a lot about avoiding that dreaded Pay to Win scenario. It is entirely possible to play through the game forever without any payments or boosts and feel like you are advancing at a fair rate. Nothing feels overpowered and I’ve regularly managed to take out players well above my level using standard weapons and vehicles, even when many of them would have advantages based around certification upgrade.

John’s constant emphasis on preventing abuse or imbalance between paid and free, which is well summarized in a blog post from August where he claims his ideal F2P system is based on League of Legends, is integral to the long term survival on a game that is incredibly reliant on teamwork. Not since Tribes have I felt that this issue has been highlighted or planned as well as it is in PS2 and I hope it continues without any creeping throughout its life.

But ironing down a balanced system of fair perpetual battle isn’t the only area where PlanetSide 2 excels. One of the most standout achievements is rooted in the methods that it uses to keep you planted and immersed within the fight. Death is rarely more than a short spawn away before you’re back into the action, and its disadvantages and challenges are more based around how complex your plans are and how far inside enemy lines you have placed yourself. Then there are the numerous “cool” moments, like getting into a dropship with your entire squad, hanging out the window taking in view with your turret, floating over the top of a tank battalion providing cover as they trundle across the rocky landscape to the next point. It’s worth bumping everything up to Max just to admire the detail on everything, from the curved end of a tank’s turret, the rippled edges on Vena armour or simply the industrial enormity of the larger bases.

Combat is fast, frenetic and extraordinarily brutal, especially after the initial drop post-intro (which is primed to put you into the most furious fight currently active), where it’s almost guaranteed that you will die. Constantly. The starting weapons are perfectly fine for most long and medium range encounters, but I highly recommend investigating before randomly choosing unlocks – many of the weapons are designed to suit particular engagements and may heavily disadvantage elements like range, magazine or fire type to dramatically increase other attributes. There are also a lot of them, and SOE has recently allowed players to design and sell their own equipment (within a certain framework), which effectively means the marketplace will grow exponentially over time.

Latency is almost non-existent on the Australian server, as it is actually hosted IN Australia, as opposed to Singapore or LA

Latency is almost non-existent on the Australian server, as it is actually hosted in Australia, as opposed to in Singapore or LA.

But it’s a testament to PS2′s netcode that the game actually performs remarkably well on the US West servers as well – in some cases (smaller battles) I actually didn’t see much of a difference, but this can change dramatically once the player count in an area increases.

Unsurprisingly, performance can dip when there are hundreds of players in a given area, alongside tanks, bikes and planes, but this isn’t something that’s unusual and it can be negated by reducing graphics options or adding/upgrading GPU(s). At time of print, the Australian server had only just come back on line after more than 12 hours offline, which SOE blamed on it not being part of its local server farm and thus harder to repair. Considering that it exists at all, I’m willing to give it a pass.

There is very little that I don’t like about PlanetSide 2, and that’s probably evident by the fact that I haven’t really mentioned many downsides. The mechanics of play, essentially, are rather basic in that it relies on the players to develop their own rivalries, territories and tactics to produce narrative in lieu of an endgame. SOE have pledged that the game will constantly evolve over time, and there is already a laundry list of suggestions, both provided by the community and the developers, of what will be introduced over the next few years. One of the most intriguing future additions involves NPC units that could temporarily aligned to a particular faction or simply as a global wildcard. This is also on top of the most demanded feature – player built and run structures.

But if there is a simple thing I miss the most from the original PlanetSide, it is that the command and rank structure has been simplified in order to appeal to a wider group of “casual” players. There are few hard restrictions on what can be used and at what time, it’s remarkably easy, resources permitting, to do almost everything you want. Certifications still prevent some of the more heavy equipment from being put in the hands of total noobs, but it doesn’t take very long before you’re piloting a Galaxy. But there is still nothing more powerful than a squad that has been primed for domination.

PlanetSide 2 delivers an experience that not only captures the original by expanding and improving on its merits, but modernises it in every conceivable way. Almost every aspect looks, sounds, plays and performs extraordinarily well, exceeding many of the metrics most people would judge a F2P game (or, frankly, an SOE game) by in the first place. It significantly raises the bar for any competitor thinking of entering the arena and effectively does to the sub-genre what GW2 has done for its MMO. Hands-down one of the best games of the year.

Good

  • LOCAL. AUSTRALIAN. SERVER.
  • Outstanding graphics, sound, latency and performance
  • Both respects and improves on the original
  • F2P system is fair, balanced and safeguarded
  • Unbelievably addictive

Bad

  • Very high learning curve
  • Rank/Command system has been dulled somewhat
  • VOIP system needs some work
Tags:
21 comments (Leave your own)

“Catalysts, Alloys and Polymers, more on these later”
They renamed these close to the end of beta for clarity, now it’s Aerospace, Mechanized, and Infantry.

 

Thanks Benny!

 

The learning curve is a bit of a bitch, and if you run out there you’ll get your face blown off. So long as you are careful and avoid sprinting into a squad of 8 armed to the teeth with rifles.
But yeah, they did simplify leveling, upgrade points and resources. Weapons, attachments and that sort of thing still need to actually be descriptive, its hard to know what is the best to take and what you will actually use (bought the reavers rockets, and I had no use for them at all)

 
James Pinnell

bennyburner:
“Catalysts, Alloys and Polymers, more on these later”
They renamed these close to the end of beta for clarity, now it’s Aerospace, Mechanized, and Infantry.

Cheers for that. I had a mind blank on the specific names and wasn’t able to login to get those details, so Google failed me.

 
Artful-dodgeR

HAS AUSTRALIAN SERVERS…

….in theory. Yet to see one actually up.

 

“Outstanding graphics, sound, latency and performance”

I must have been playing something different,. . .

 
 

ninothin,

Mine plays smoooth as silk. Mind you I’m running on lowest settings :P Still looks alright though.

 

I find that graphics settings don’t make a single difference once I’m in a large facility with 100 other players. Going from lowest to highest results in no frame rate change.
On the Au server side of things, there’s quite a few listed in the server monitor (built in to the launcher)
Alkali, Black Ridge, Briggs, Jagged Lance, Morgannis, Saerro, Stillwater, and Vaemar are all listed as Aussie servers. Perhaps they’ll bring them online as more oceanic players join…

 
James Pinnell

ninothin:
“Outstanding graphics, sound, latency and performance”

I must have been playing something different,. . .

I’ve been running it on 1920 with everything up high on a Radeon HD 6950 with a last gen i7 and 16gb RAM. I’m also running it off an SSD.

So my rig might be higher than average but I honestly haven’t noticed any slowdown or latency issues. In early beta performance was dreadful but it very noticeably improved about a month ago and since then it has been very smooth.

 
James Pinnell

bennyburner:

Alkali, Black Ridge, Briggs, Jagged Lance, Morgannis, Saerro, Stillwater, and Vaemar are all listed as Aussie servers. Perhaps they’ll bring them online as more oceanic players join…

SOE basically shipped everything, including backup and future servers, in one go apparently, so it wouldn’t surprise me if they had some virtual or physical servers waiting to meet capacity.

 

Apologies if I’ve missed this in the article, but any details as to what’s lacking in the VOIP system atm?

 
James Pinnell

jez:
Apologies if I’ve missed this in the article, but any details as to what’s lacking in the VOIP system atm?

I didn’t want to dedicate a section in the review, especially since its long enough as it is, but I didn’t find the inbuilt VOIP system too crash hot.

it might have just been my experience, but I found it a bit clumsy to operate and the audio would randomly go loud and soft, cut out and in, and platoon/squad chat would operate even if I left. It just felt a bit buggy and messy.

I had similar problems to these – http://forums.station.sony.com/ps2/index.php?threads/voip-platoon-squad-chat-is-intermittent-broken.47759/

 

Ah, well I’m downloading the game now, will see how it works for me.

 

Is the game-play anything like Tribes: Ascend? I ask because I gave Tribes a fair shot but just couldn’t get into it…might have been my lack of FPS skill than the game itself.

I like the looks of Planetside 2 but I liked the looks of Tribes too so just wondering how similar they are before using my limited bandwidth.

 
James Pinnell

kendrite:
Is the game-play anything like Tribes: Ascend? I ask because I gave Tribes a fair shot but just couldn’t get into it…might have been my lack of FPS skill than the game itself.

I like the looks of Planetside 2 but I liked the looks of Tribes too so just wondering how similar they are before using my limited bandwidth.

It’s really nothing like Tribes – it’s much more like Battlefield if I had to make a direct comparison.

 

re: SOE’s stationcash etc, I’ve really come around on the whole deal. I played EQII for quite some time and initially looking at the F2P version of it, was a bit annoyed at what seemed to be a lot of nickel and diming for basic functionality.

Then I discovered sales. 2:1 or 3:1 station cash sales, in game sales etc… Not only that, the points are universal to all their titles which have a SC shop.

So if you do want to flash some cash on PS2 gear but don’t want to pay full price, keep an eye out for sales on points and/or in game. Currently they have an infantry starter pack which has a fair amount of swag for 2000 points (20 bucks, 1 point = 1 cent) down from 4000. Use 3:1 points for that and it’s 6.70 for 40 bucks of virtual “value” (mileage may vary for those that consider buying items in game a silly thing to do ; )

This whole retooling of the system has really revitalised some of their older titles (EQII has much greater populations now than it did a couple of years ago for example) and I think PS2 will benefit greatly in that anyone can play anytime and do well and unlock almost anything they want without spending a cent.

 
FiveThirtyBird

Space CoD. Pay2Win. Buggy. Paid GON review.

 

Personally this is currently tied with Borderlands 2 and The Secret World as my game of the year. The team have gone to great lengths to get the Aussie server working, pulling 20 hour days in the office over a public holiday. It seems to have worked – I played last night for hours on end without any problems.

There’s nothing else out there like this game, and the sense of scale is simple boggling. Given that its Free to Play, I highly recommend that any shooter player should check it out. JUST MAKE SURE YOU WATCH THESE TUTORIAL VIDEOS FIRST: http://www.planetside2.com/game-tutorials

 
James Pinnell

FiveThirtyBird:
Paid GON review.

Oh grow up.

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

YouTube

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
Heroes of the Storm

Heroes of the Storm: We talk to Blizzard about new heroes, rage quitting, and why they want you to spend money on Stimpacks

What's up with Stimpacks? And how about those Goblin Techies spotted in the game files? We ask Blizzard for details.

the crew-580w-4

The Crew: A gorgeous open world, if you can handle the interruptions

Alex drives across the United States and back to bring you his thoughts.

Game of the Year 2014

Win a PS4 in our Game of the Year 2014 Competition!

Think you know who should take home the crown? Share your thoughts and win!

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

Facebook Like Box