Natural Selection 2 reviewed: One of PC gaming’s best is reborn, but new players may struggle

Natural Selection 2

By and on November 8, 2012 at 12:59 pm

Alex Walker: The world was a vastly different place when the original Natural Selection was launched. The United Nations had passed Resolution 1441 demanding Iraq co-operate with weapons inspectors. Australians were still recovering from the dual bombings in Kuta, Bali and the fallout of the Nord-Ost siege in Moscow, which saw around 170 people,  including 129 hostages and 9 foreigners, lose their lives.

But the world of gaming was looking brighter than ever, thanks to the industry of Charlie “Flayra” Cleveland, who managed to do more with a free Half-Life modification than so many studios had managed beforehand. He achieved the holy grail: successfully combining the RTS and FPS genres in a way that refused to dumb down the mechanics of either, while maintaining a heavy emphasis on team-play that was aligned perfectly with the gaming landscape at the time.

That was ten years ago, and things have changed remarkably since then. Instead of Counter-Strike and Quake, gamers think of Call of Duty and Halo when they talk about an FPS. Developers still saturate the market with team-based shooters, but the emphasis has almost permanently shifted to the individual’s role rather than the collective efforts of all.

Enter Natural Selection 2:, a labour of love that took precisely six years to deliver (the game was first announced in October 2006, with the original also being released on Halloween four years prior). But this isn’t a title that caters to the current trends. Refusal to co-operate will get you killed. Failing to communicate effectively will get you killed. John Rambo’s 12-year-old cousin has no place here.

And it feels good.

James Pinnell: Indeed it does, Alex. A decade has done nothing but whet many appetites for a modern version of Natural Selection, and it’s interesting that its creation would not have even been realised if it wasn’t for the support of an extraordinarily dedicated community. Before Kickstarter, IndieGoGo and Pozible, NS2 was unintentionally pioneering the direct-to-fanbase preorder system that has become the first point of call for ambitious independent titles.

NS2 began its long, gradual ascend to reality as a modification to Valve’s venerable Source engine, but it quickly dawned on the developers that the restrictions of the ageing beast would not allow them to build the scope of design that they wanted. They appealed to the community, many of whom still played the original HL1 mod regularly, to back them on an uncertain journey through the design phase of a custom engine, a plethora of bugs, constant build updates and an unknown end date. Tens of thousands (including your insanely handsome reviewers) signed on immediately.

The final result is nothing short of fantastic, especially considering the number of obstacles encountered by the team along the way. Very little has changed to the formula, which for the uninitiated, involves a tense Alien Vs Marine battle in which each side is headed up by a Commander, a player who directs the building of resource collectors, researching upgrades and weapons, and points players to enemy activity via a top down interface.

Players can “Evolve” in the case of the Aliens, which is effectively a change of class, where the Marines have their weapons and armour upgraded and utilise a number of various mechanical tools. What makes NS2 so brilliant is that both sides are so well balanced; for instance, Marines have the luxury of distance via rifle fire, while Aliens can blend into their environment to launch stealthy melee attacks.

Unknown Worlds have been especially careful to keep the flavour right for the sequel, since, largely, most of the hard yards were ironed out in the original.

Alex: But what’s so gratifying is that the sheer amount of skill and depth for people willing to traverse its depths. As an alien, everyone immediately spawns as a Skulk, a zergling-type unit that has the ability to climb walls simply by running at them.

If you’re new to the game, you can simply run up the walls, find a roof somewhere and wait for a Marine to arrive before dropping on their face and mauling the life out of them. That’s fine. But spend a few hours on YouTube and in-game and you’ll discover a new world of parkour-esque movement, flying off walls and leaping past Marines to throw their aim off.

It’s symptomatic of Natural Selection as a whole. There’s the elements you’re given on the surface and the basic idea of how the units are supposed to work and function, but it’s not until you really delve into the game that you begin to appreciate the complexity of how NS2 flows, each players piece in that puzzle, and the ways a game can be turned around.

Here’s some gameplay footage we recorded — click here if you’d like to download it from the file mirror in HD.

The video player is not available. Please visit the article on to watch.

But while the depth and scope of the “big picture” that takes place is its most addictive trait, it’s also the most cumbersome for anyone lacking half a decade or more of experience. The only tutorials available are a string of YouTube videos accessible from the game’s main menu, as well as a “explore mode” that lets you try out both races, the various evolutions and weapons and learn the various ins and outs of buildings, abilities and so on.

The videos are instructive enough, but the game is steeped in an old-school philosophy in that you need to develop a “feel” for how everything moves and functions. You don’t learn how to fly at 100 miles an hour; it comes through practice. And this is only the basics of movement; learning how to command is a completely different beast, which takes tens of hours to nail down just to prevent your team-mates from rebelling.

Unknown Worlds could have greased the wheels substantially with some in-game tutorials to help players become accustomed to the basics of the Aliens and Commander roles especially. You can select a “rookie mode” from the options menu, which is activated until a player has logged at least 4 hours of gameplay. Other players are told to help their newer colleagues through a hint on the loading screen, but it’s not really sufficient. A series of tool-tips, perhaps the ones used in the Explore Mode, could be activated in multiplayer for greenhorns until their experience grows.

James: The same applies for how structures work and how to place them. Commanders will bark orders at you to travel to a part of the map to kill or build something, but without any sort of guide it can be very daunting to find it. A minimap wouldn’t go astray, nor would a simple guide on what each class can and can’t do.

But discovery is also a magnificent way to learn, and in most matches people are usually willing to give people the benefit of the doubt. Advanced abilities, like the Fade’s “blink”, are invaluable if used correctly, and require a lot of trial and error to complete. The same goes with placing defensive structures or choosing the correct time to lay down a refinery or hive.

Nostalgia came flooding in like water on the Titanic’s lower decks when I heard the “ding dong” of a new waypoint or the rough gnashing of a skulks teeth

The huge generational gap between the old and new games also provides a bit of a leeway to allow rookies to catch up with veterans. Most players I’ve found have been pretty sloppy, struggling to command players when they are still learning the interface. Much of the fun of NS was always the sheer spontaneity of strategy, surprising your enemy by heading straight for their commander, or splitting into two teams to force a tough decision.

But these things will iron themselves out. What UW have done is effectively rebuild NS in their new engine, tweak some of the ways you evolve, or in the Marine’s case, add the option of robots to help repair or build equipment. It reminds me a lot of StarCraft 2 in a way, bringing the game into the modern era with a great looking maps, animations and effects. A lot of it still looks rough, but the game is still evolving, every single day.

Some elements have been wholeheartedly ripped straight out of the original, like some of the sound assets and the basic layout of the player models. Nostalgia came flooding in like water on the Titanic’s lower decks when I heard the “ding dong” of a new waypoint or the rough gnashing of a skulks teeth as it attempts to rip apart an unsuspecting soldier.

Alex: Strangely, I quite like the custom engine UW built. It’s not up to Frostbite 2 standards, obviously, but it’s not an ugly beast either. The dynamic infestation works quite well from the first-person perspective; it’s quite vibrant and a treat to look at (although I jumped into NS after the gun-barrel grey misery that was the new Medal of Honor, so take that how you will). It creates some technical challenges though, with the infestation regularly popping in from the commander’s perspective as you scroll across the map.

That’s been the only real glitch I’ve encountered. That’s not to say there haven’t been significant bugs, but the fact that my experience has been unencumbered so far is an increasingly rare trait in the online age, particularly with the prevalence of day-one DLC. It’s worth mentioning that there’s a live feed of the developer’s official Twitter at the bottom of the menu screen, which occasionally keeps you updated on bug fixes.

Provided you can tolerate the not-insubstantial learning curve, and the misery of the odd game with a bad commander, there are fewer no-brain choices you can make with your gaming dollar

There’s also a bevy of useless re-tweets and nonsense, but it highlights the developer’s persistence in engaging with the community. And that’s the crux of what NS2 is all about. This is a game that was built from the ground up by one guy and was kept alive through the diverse strength and passion of the fans who were happy to pre-order years in advance to fund development.

If you play NS2, you are playing with one of the older communities in gaming. You are playing with a developer who has been personally attached to the IP for a decade. Updates and servers will continue to roll out for years, along with a string of mods and maps from the community.

Provided you can tolerate the not-insubstantial learning curve, and the misery of the odd game with a bad commander, there are fewer no-brain choices you can make with your gaming dollar this year than buying into Natural Selection 2 and the love that its fans have for it. Unless you happen to have a savage dislike of intelligent, asymmetrical team-based shooters with a high focus on communication, teamwork and strategy. But in that case, you’re probably a bit of an Alien anyway.


  • Stellar effort of modernising a PC gaming classic
  • Great engine, performance and sound
  • Strong community of dedicated players
  • Beautifully balanced, asymmetrical gameplay


  • Very newbie unfriendly, high learning curve
  • Still a few bugs floating around

You can buy the digital deluxe version of Natural Selection 2 direct from the developers for $40, or you can buy the plain ol’ vanilla version on Steam instead for $25.

15 comments (Leave your own)

Is it still crazy twitch-based? I found the original waay too fast to get into when i tried it

James Pinnell

In the thick of it, yes, it can get pretty intense.


I miss playing the role of “Engineer” by being a gorge since the inclusion of the new “Alien Commander” =(
Which goes somewhat hand in hand with the lack of offensive towers/turrets buildable and that they really suck compared to the original – though I can fully see where they were trying to go with this iteration; in the direction of more “Player & squad communication” based rather then the traditional RTS “Lock down an area with ‘guard towers’ place and forget” approach.

“A minimap wouldn’t go astray”
It does have a mini-map, when playing marines it’s actually quite useful to keep an eye on it for seeing the enemy represented via red dots that your other squadmates have a visual on and/or your commander has scanner sweeped. Unless your talking about an entire level map, which you can bring up by pressing ‘C’.

James Pinnell

“A minimap wouldn’t go astray”
It does have a mini-map, when playing marines it’s actually quite useful to keep an eye on it for seeing the enemy represented via red dots that your other squadmates have a visual on and/or your commander has scanner sweeped. Unless your talking about an entire level map, which you can bring up by pressing ‘C’.

Aliens don’t have a minimap, although they have other navigation functions, it can be difficult to quickly find an area.


Just press C and you’ll get your bearings pretty quickly.


Is it still crazy twitch-based?I found the original waay too fast to get into when i tried it

It’s not as fast as in, there’s no more bunny hopping like there when NS1 was on the HL1 engine. That said, marines now have sprint. The maps are also a bit smaller because the ‘nothing’ rooms are gone making the gaps between action shorter.

(Nothing room in NS1 where the typical ‘rally’ bases in which marines would attack a hives).

For the newbies to NS2, don’t try commanding (the RTS element) to begin with. Stick with at least one team-mate. Listen to calls for incoming and defence. Report info about incoming enemies, buildings being constructed.

Also there’s a wiki –

If you have questions, then ask! I’ve found the NS2 community to be quite friendly.

James Pinnell

Just press C and you’ll get your bearings pretty quickly.

Oh, believe me, I’m happy with the map – the minimap is just a suggestion which would help new players of the arguably more difficult Alien race.


I played the mod years ago but not much because by the time I tried it it was virtually dead. Anyway I think its a little bad for beginners but its not too bad I quickly got into the way of things and even tried Commander one game when no-one else took the helm. We lost but I didn’t do too badly.


a game that blends rts and fps requires thought and practice. serious noobs need not apply.

contender for GOTY 2012 imo.


I’m finding it relatively quick to pick up and I am quite enjoying it tbh. It feels rough around the edges here and there like it’s RIDICULOUSLY easy to get lost even when you have the map up and I feel like there should be a cap on Exo suits and Onos’s. It just becomes an absolute clusterf*ck when you have 4+ of either of the running around not to mention impossible to fight against.


“You don’t learn how to fly at 100 miles an hour; it comes through practice.”

Also, this looks amazing.


doublepostlevelup the download link is bloken.


doublepostlevelup the download link is bloken.

I just downloaded it then with no problems – maybe try again?


I don’t enjoy it as much as the first, purely because the Australian community is not as fun to play with as the old communities I used to play with, perhaps I’m just getting old and disgruntled.


NS has always been a freakin amazing game. The high learning curve in NS1 is what actually drove me to learn everything about it I could and to get better.

In my opinion, learning curves are good.

Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href=""]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014


Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Releasing Soon
Thief Shadowrun Returns South Park: The Stick of Truth

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
Dark Souls 2

Dark Souls 2 PC reviewed: The sweet reprise of death

Jason Imms dies over and over to bring you the skinny on the PC version of Dark Souls 2.

The Elder Scrolls Online Grabnadz

The Elder Scrolls Online journals: One giant, kinda laggy leap for orc-kind

Levels one through fifteen of The Elder Scrolls Online are demolished by an angry orc mage-tank.

Watch Dogs

Watch Dogs PC hands-on: Not the perfect open world, but still a world of fun

Watch Dogs offers a generous array of options, and we push the boundaries to see how far we can go.


Heroes of the Storm: Blizzard’s Dustin Browder on rage problems, hybrid roles, and balance

"We’re trying to make it so if there’s something obvious that you want to do, it’s the right thing to do. There’s no sort of hidden rules or hidden strategies that make that wrong."


ArcheAge’s alpha impressions: The freeform Korean MMO that might just live up to its promises

This high-flying Korean MMO has finally made it to a Western release. James jumps in to see if the promise 'sandpark' model delivers.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

The Regulars

Sitrep: Hating Guns and Totally Loving Playing With Guns

Toby's absent-minded shower thoughts arrive for your edification.

The Secret World

Legal Opinion: Bait and switch… with a mankini

Not everybody is laughing following Funcom's April Fools joke on its players.

Bad at Aiming

Sitrep: Waiting in line at the FPS dole queue

Toby is so incompetent that he needs an entire new genre of games invented just to cater for him.

Amazon Fire

Friday Tech Roundup (04 April 2014): Radeon R9 295X2 specs leak

Also, the man behind the "Microsoft" phone scam has been captured and fined.

Facebook Like Box