Medal Of Honor: Warfighter’s single-player reviewed: The year’s least ambitious shooter

Medal of Honor: Warfighter

By on October 26, 2012 at 5:12 pm

As the single-player and multi-player components for Medal of Honor: Warfighter are so different, we’re doing different reviews of each. We’ll bring you our multi-player review next week once we’ve had more time to get to grips with the game modes and the current state of balance. For now, here’s our review of the game’s single-player campaign.

My mother told me a story once about a time when my father had a gun pointed to his head in the Middle East. He was working on an oil tanker going through the Gulf at the time. It was before the first Iraq war as far as I know: I say this because he stopped working on oil tankers and started making a lot of trips to Japan shipping iron ore around the early 90s.

One thing that hasn’t changed, be it the 80s or the 90s, was my father’s beard; he’s had it for at least four decades, probably longer. Another thing that never seemed to change was what my mother, in her colourful manner, described as his “Jewish” look. He’s not Jewish. But he was held at gunpoint the end of a wharf for three hours until someone could vouch that this was the case.

Luckily, someone did.

I’ve heard him recall the incident a couple of times since then; he shrugs it off, although he’s not the exuberant type when it comes to storytelling so that’s kind of a standard response. But I remember it reasonably well for two reasons.

The first is that I never saw my dad a great deal when I was growing up. He was, quite literally, overseas for half my life. That’s not an exaggeration; his work schedule gave him one day off for every day at sea. Before I was born and shortly afterwards, it was six months on, six months off. That narrowed down to 3 months each way when I started going to primary school, and then to two months and finally to six weeks (although occasionally delays have extended that slightly).

For the last two decades he’s never been in any danger, but he’s been in situations like the one above where, as my mother recounted, it would have been simpler for his Arabian “friends” to put a bullet in his head and be done with it.

Secondly, the story is just plain hard to forget — with the two Iraq wars and the Afghanistan conflict, which has sadly resulted in the loss of many brave Diggers. None of my family is involved in the Army, but I can at least empathise with the prospect of losing a parent while they’re working overseas.

Which is how we get to Medal of Honor: Warfighter.

There are two elements to Danger Close’s new special forces-centric shooter. The first is a plot involving a bunch of grizzled, middle-aged servicemen hunting down Arabic terrorists across the globe in the Middle East, Southeast Asia, Bosnia, Somalia and some oceans somewhere.

This part you’ve seen already, provided you’ve played at least one video game involving guns and a first-person perspective in the last decade and haven’t recently suffered a stroke. But the second is a series of cutscenes focusing on the fragmented relationship between Preacher – one of the protagonists – and his family.

Being special forces, he doesn’t see them a great deal. It’s understandable: you’re having a conversation with your family one minute, work calls the next and then you’re on another continent 24 hours later. They don’t know why, but they know not to ask.

What complicates matters somewhat is the overlying “hook” of Warfighter: the story was written by two active Tier 1 operators. Most of the missions start with a note in the bottom left that says “Inspired by Actual Events”. Whether Danger Close/EA want us to think that means “this actually happened but we can’t really tell you about it so here’s this other thing that seems plausible”, I don’t know.

That culminates at the end of the campaign. It’s difficult to talk about this section – there’s a small story following the final cutscene – without spoiling it, but it’s not until then that the “truth”, or I suppose the real message of the game, becomes clear.

And it wasn’t until that message was revealed that I became, well, probably the angriest I’ve been in a while.

It’s not that the campaign is really bad by any measure. The nuts and bolts of the game come courtesy of DICE’s Frostbite 2 engine, which does a fine job of rendering anything you can throw at it. I’m running a i5-3750K with a factory overclocked 660 Ti and a few SSDs, and as expected, the game pumped out at a flawless rate of knots without batting an eyelid.

Strangely though, the best use of the technology is in the cutscenes. Without watching it yourselves on a fullscreen, the closest example I can think of is what Pixar would make if they decided to ditch the cartoons for exceptionally lifelike, but animated, productions. There’s a noticeable lack of colour in some of the scenes, but it’s a deliberate effect rather than a limitation. It accentuates the idea that the protagonist’s relationship is actually sapping away his life-force, that he’s slowly seeping into depression.

You don’t buy a first-person shooter for the tears; you buy it for the non-stop action, and while there is most certainly a great deal of gunfire, I’d be lying if I said any of it was memorable

That’s probably part of why I was so peeved, simply because the rendering was so bloody good. If DICE ever saw fit to release the technology to machinima fans, you’d see some extraordinary movies; it’s clearly a wonderful, wonderful piece of coding.

But I digress. You don’t buy a first-person shooter for the tears; you buy it for the non-stop action, and while there is most certainly a great deal of gunfire, I’d be lying if I said any of it was memorable. The first mission has you creeping behind an enemy with orders to take him out, a pursuit you literally cannot fail at as the game prevents you from aiming away from his head.

It’s a curious decision: if you can’t trust me to accurately pull the trigger at this stage, why not take away the control and then run through a training stage later?

As it turns out, that’s pretty much what happens. Rather than opening with a tutorial, however, Danger Close have gone for the “opening door” technique. Start things off with a big bang and lots of action. You know, just like Call of Duty. And then you run through the basics, including a timed obstacle course in a faux airplane.

And that checkbox mentality, meeting whatever benchmarks Call of Duty set half a decade ago, can be applied throughout the campaign. Obligatory long-range sniping mission? Check. Gunning down terrorists from a helicopter? Check. Kill stuff with a cool piece of equipment? Check. Enemies that constantly spawn unless you move forward? Check. An annoyingly linear path complete with obnoxious invisible walls, even in open areas? Check. Slow-motion after a breach? Multiple checks.

There’s no nuance here. You’re literally told at several points to move from cover to cover, as if Warfighter will somehow be the first shooter a gamer has ever played. There’s even a couple of chase scenes that are, again, almost identical in length and style to what gamers have come to expect from any first-person shooter.

But Danger Close’s idea of what can pass for a AAA-shooter in this day and age might be well below gamers’ expectations. Whenever your squad lines up to breach a door, you’ll be given a half-circle of options, from merely kicking the door in, blowing off the handle with a shotgun, using a strip of The World’s Most Explosive Duct Tape or even a cute little charge that hangs off the doorknob.

At best the campaign is mediocre, which I suppose in a way makes it even worse than if it was genuinely bad. If something’s horrendous, it’s at least memorable

Sadly, none of the options make any difference, except for the fact that they waste your time just that little bit more. Which would be nothing more than a mild annoyance, if for the fact that your time wasn’t already being wasted by the inconsistent squad AI. Occasionally, they would save me the trouble of having to shoot things myself, while other times they’d happily stand by and hold down the trigger at a target 4000 miles away while I’m getting shot at point blank range by a terrorist within arm’s reach. Seriously.

At best the campaign is mediocre, something you can say about any first-person shooter these days, which I suppose in a way makes it even worse than if it was genuinely bad. If something’s horrendous, it’s at least memorable. I feel bad for even saying that, because in the back of my mind I keep thinking I’m basically just denigrating what, for all I know, could actually be a true story.

But even though that may be the case, the reality is that the actual experience of the campaign — what the game actually asks you to sit down and do — has been done. All of it. There’s nothing you haven’t done in Warfighter that wasn’t done somewhere else, and better. It’s more plausible than Battlefield 3 or Call of Duty but also less interesting; it doesn’t set a new benchmark, let alone even try.

Perhaps the only part of gameplay that could manages to stand out is an odd driving mission — yes, driving — where you’re trying to escape with a target without attracting the attention of various patrols. It’s intriguing if only because it’s so different from the typical chase/drive away set-piece.  But even that spark of innovation is limited; you’re effectively stuck to a couple of blocks and one highway to drive down. You could try a sneaky U-turn to throw off your pursuers, but the game won’t have any of that; the only way forward is quite literally the path ahead of you.

And that’s the true disappointment, especially considering that Warfighter is constantly trying to make you empathise with what the game quite literally describes as superheroes: the men and women that make up special forces units around the world.

Commandos are amazing. They’re the closest thing we have to superhumans, considering the sacrifices and the feats of endurance, strength and willpower that’s expected of them. None of those qualities are present in the campaign though: it’s just ordinary and completely forgettable.

Diggers, or any other serving member of the armed forces for that matter, deserve a better tribute than this.

Good

  • Cut scenes are superbly rendered – perhaps the best yet
  • Driving around Dubai mission was an interesting diversion, if limited
  • Frostbite 2 still looks amazing

Bad

  • Uninspired gameplay; probably the least ambitious shooter this year
  • Inconsistent squad AI
  • Effectively the same FPS you’ve been playing for the last 5 years
26 comments (Leave your own)

I have been very disappointed by MoH after a few hours of play last night. I was one of its most vocal supporters and even read the Destructoid review thinking “you don’t understand what the game is about, what you’ve described is what I’ve been waiting for”.

But oh dear god. All I’ll say at this point is that on Console it looks absolutely appalling. The first MoH’s SP on Unreal 3 looked better than this. And breaching, utterly retarded.. I’m last in the room of my four-man squad and because the graphics are so jagged and hideous I can’t see all the enemies to kill them so I die, over and over, while my squadmates just stand there.

So, so, so sad. This was my BF3/CoD replacement but now it’s just a 7-day return.

 
HandsomeSandwich

Why are the first 400 words of a game review dedicated to the borderline demonising of Arabs and giving no F about the actual victims of mentioned wars, which number in the millions.

 

This is disappointing. I greatly enjoyed the first MoH (the reboot, that is).

What’s funny, though, is that this review could probably be attributed to every COD game following Modern Warfare (which was fantastic). It makes me sad that those games do so well when they achieve so little in terms of actual innovation.

One question: how well were international forces represented during the game? They played that up a lot for the marketing, but I wasn’t sure if it was only for the multiplayer.

 

handsomesandwich:
Why are the first 400 words of a game review dedicated to the borderline demonising of Arabs and giving no F about the actual victims of mentioned wars, which number in the millions.

Borderline demonising of Arabs?!

 

Well said. I hope trash like this stops selling well and does so soon. Sadly at the moment anything with a Call Of Duty or Battlefield logo (and to a lesser extent, Medal of Honour) on it sells like hotcakes. Modern shooters like this are unoriginal and uninteresting. I’m utterly sick of seeing shelves full of them. Its been done to death! Try something different and take a risk once in a while. BF2142 didn’t sell that poorly and despite not being particularly good, it was still something different that hadn’t been done a thousand times. Unless something astounding comes out, I think I’m well and truly done with modern shooters.

 

ausjoker,

*selects Australian unit for Multiplayer* “Alright mate”.

That (seriously) plus your chosen country’s flag as a patch on the uniform. That’s IT.

 

Somehow I’m disappointed yet completely unsurprised by the review.

 
SilentWolf.AUS

Murray Hibble,

Are you referring to how the different multiplayer classes are poorly differentiated?

If so, that’s a pretty massive cop out, would have really expected some cool country specific abilities n whatnot.

 

I learnt my lesson not to Pre-order EA or Activision games a long time ago, guess I’ll be waiting for this one to hit the bargain bins before picking it up.

Am I correct to presume that it’s just a re-skinned Battlefield 3 for the Multi-player as well?

 

silentwolfaus,

Yeah, the only difference when I pick my Australian soldier is he says “Let’s go mate” and has our flag as a patch on his uniform. Not sure what I expected really, but with character models that are almost minecraft-esque in their blocky blandness I have run out of the will to even feel disappointed.

Still, I have the SP campaign to go and I will put some more time into MP. Such a shame, the original MoH reboot was, for me, the best multiplayer out there. The right size maps, infantry-centric, simple kill-streak rewards and amazing graphics/sound… how on earth they made it into this muddy shitpile of blurred textures has me flummoxed.

They honestly should have stuck with Unreal, they knew what they were doing with that.

 

Murray Hibble:
silentwolfaus,
They honestly should have stuck with Unreal, they knew what they were doing with that.

Actually the reboot’s Multi-player used Frostbite and was made by Dice, this game is handled by another team completely.

 

I’m talking about the Single Player from MoH in 2007… they did that on Unreal 3. Everything about it looked great and if they’d have used that for this year’s multi I’d have been stoked. The MP MoH in 2007 (made by Dice) used Frostbite (1.0 I think) and was gorgeous, environments looked great and even just the ground textures were really pretty.

Jump forward to MoH:WF’s MP and the ground textures and environments in general are muddied and look far older than the original reboot. Clearly the Danger Close team is adept with the U3 engine and clearly they’re not up to the task of using Frostbite like Dice did.

And unsure what you mean by ‘handled by another team’, this year it’s all Danger Close.

 

It’s not like you weren’t warned, I did say have fun with the jaggies :)

 

I preferred MoHW SP a lot more then MoH (2012) SP, at least this time around Danger Close went for some diversity to keep it slight more interesting. But yeah I don’t really play these games for the short 6 hour SP as MP is where the fun lies for me at least.

 

I picked this game up for the MP since I heard from some youtube reviewers it was pretty damn good.

And it is kinda solid, quite like it still needs polish though. I’ll likely not touch the campaign.

 

handsomesandwich:
Why are the first 400 words of a game review dedicated to the borderline demonising of Arabs and giving no F about the actual victims of mentioned wars, which number in the millions.

Dafuque?

 

The game isn’t that terrible. I’ve definitely had worse experiences with other games. The multiplayer is different, it feels like you need to use cover, not just run out in the open and shoot everything you see.

Single player I’ve only played a little, I’m not really interested in the story because it’s usually the same thing.

 

I didn’t see the first 400 words as demonising Arabs, but I did see it as a poor intro. I felt the eventual segue was pretty clumsy, too.

As for the substance of the review, the following made me very unlikely to pick this game up:

‘Enemies that constantly spawn unless you move forward? Check. An annoyingly linear path complete with obnoxious invisible walls, even in open areas?’. No thanks.

 

Murray Hibble:
I’m talking about the Single Player from MoH in 2007… they did that on Unreal 3.

The Medal of Honor you’re referring to was 2010. Medal of Honor : Airborne was the 2007 one, but it did also happen to run on Unreal 3.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medal_of_Honor:_Airborne
.

 

Alex Walker’s dad had a beard.
Alex Walker’s dad is awesome.

 
Leave a comment

You can use the following bbCode
[i], [b], [img], [quote], [url href="http://www.google.com/"]Google[/url]

Leave a Reply

PC Gaming Calendar 2014

Follow Games.on.net

YouTube

Steam Group

Upcoming Games

Community Soapbox

Recent Features
far_cry_4_2

Far Cry 4: Wielding the will to power

"A living being seeks above all else to discharge its strength. Life itself is will to power. Nothing else matters."

battlecry

Will Battlecry dethrone Dota or de-hat TF2? We play the game and speak to the team

In a world where gunpowder is banned, nations just stab each other instead to solve problems. We jump right in.

gta_5_ps4_xb1_1

Grand Theft Auto 5 comes alive on next-gen: We look at the PS4 re-release

With a completely overhauled engine and a new first-person mode, is GTA V's next-gen release worth your time?

amd_gear_winners

Gear up for Christmas with AMD: Winners announcement!

'Twas the month before Christmas, and all through the house...

dragon_age_inquisition_review_20

Inquisition is “a new foundation” for BioWare: We chat to Mike Laidlaw

Why can't you have an entire party of dogs? Why can't I turn into a swarm of bees? We ask these important questions and more.

Streaming Radio
Radio Streams are restricted to iiNet group customers.

GreenManGaming MREC

Facebook Like Box